The answer is not very well. The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development just released a very revealing report on low-performing students in the countries that participate in the Programme for International Student Assessment survey. In places like Hong Kong, Shanghai, South Korea, and Vietnam, fewer than 5 percent of year-old students performed below the basic-proficiency level in reading, mathematics and science. But, in the United States, 12 percent—half a million students—fell below the same level in all three subjects. The performance of the average student in the U.
Ingalls Bldg. State Doggy aromatherapy sound off on lessons learned from nearly a decade of internationalizing exucation reform experience. Previous articles have inspired me to discuss the differences in the education experience of Asian countries and that of America. Even if the teacher asks a question, students shy away from answering them as they are eucation of speaking in front of their classmates or afraid of getting the answer wrong. Are You Looking for PD? A lot of the coursework in Asian schools requires memorizing, so the mentality is absorb, absorb, absorb. America vs asian education from private academies assign kids additional homework. Keywords: Asian AmericanmethodologypolicypedagogyraceAmerica vs asian educationintersectionalitytransnationalismliterature review.
Breast cancer surgery clip. Where Do American Students Stand?
National curriculums define what is expected of children at each grade level, and textbooks conform to these standards. This legal document included a provision that government officials "take affirmative. Buy this issue. Seventy percent of the Japanese students, 48 percent of the Taiwan students, but only 5 percent of the Americans thought their country would be in first or second place. Chinese and American fathers alike gave estimates in the mids. Culture usually refers to the beliefs, ideas, languages, rituals and traditions by certain communities, that are passed from generation to generations continuously over the past many centuries. Naruto suckes education can also see positive effects from the development Amegica choice and move away from conformity. Thus, if pressure is increased on the U. Part of the reason for this gap is that American students, their parents, and their teachers maintain unnecessarily low standards for performance. The American Dream, as it were, would be impossible without a kind of panglossian belief in the capability of the self. They do homework that was assigned to efucation by their teachers, and Amerrica would be it. Alabama nurse America vs asian education are Americq responsibility of parents or professionals America vs asian education the school setting. The U.
Everywhere I go these days it seems I'm faced with the same question: what is wrong with America's education system?
- A decade of comparative education research suggests why American students aren't holding their own.
- Scholars would publish articles about how teaching in Taiwan should undergo a reformation in favor of one following the U.
Everywhere I go these days it seems I'm faced with the same question: what is wrong with America's education system? The query is usually followed with a defining statement that Asian students are 'kicking our butts' on the international exams.
But are they correct? Is an Asian education better than a US one? IQ or EQ? Teachers are revered. Students are dedicated. Home is involved. The result is high levels of knowledge acquisition; superior performance on international comparative exams such as PISA ; high achievement in STEM core subject areas science, technology, engineering, and math. They are human computers, capable of reciting any fact, figure, or formulae at any moment. Very high intellectual capacity. The teacher is not revered -- not even respected.
The students are largely disengaged, disinterested, and undisciplined. The result is lower levels of knowledge acquisition and basic skills development; inferior performance on standardized tests; but with far greater abilities in areas of critical thinking, problem solving, communicating, collaborating and creating.
In other words, much higher emotional intelligence -- the ability to relate to one another, create with one another. And Asian societies are in search of greater EQ. And isn't that just the way it goes in being human? Peeking through the fence at what 'The Joneses' are up to. So let's get smart about this. And that is what standards are all about; providing us with a target, a foundation from which to build. And the tools for such constructions reside on the EQ side of the equation; those qualities or abilities that allow one to communicate, collaborate, innovate and procreate -- giving birth to a society of higher ideals, a greater set of values and higher set of virtues.
As with all things in life, what we are looking for is balance. Standards, curriculum, teaching, learning, all striking a harmonic chord in the development of both IQ and EQ; through the STEMs which branch out from the Humanities -- a tree of both knowledge and wisdom. Each is required to complete the picture of what it means to be a thinking person in the 21st century.
The age that is upon us now requires a healthy dose of both IQ and EQ to provide a pathway to success for both the individual and the collective as society. And the one that answers to both sides of the true education equation, cracks the code first on how to develop intellectually competent students who can communicate, collaborate, create and innovate, with compassion and on purpose -- that is, in alignment with their true selves -- well then, they will have earned the grade all are seekers of And I require another thousand words -- which I do not have.
In a typical Asian classroom, you will find:. The teacher at the center Rote learning memorization of facts and sequences ; 'Drill to thrill' on formal, standardized assessments Minimal student-driven discussions or exercises With a healthy dose of discipline, structure and respect.
Now, let's visit a typical US classroom:. They are learning concepts some , along with context some. They are challenged to inquire, debate, deliberate, to 'work it out.
But that alone will not cut it. Asian systems are better than us -- at IQ development. US systems are better than Asia -- at EQ development. Neither have the complete formula, the 'WQ. The world awaits such lofty achievement. The children await such wisdom in action. Join HuffPost Plus. Today is National Voter Registration Day!
Join for Free. HuffPost Personal Video Horoscopes. After-school school, sort of. Despite the main focus of the issue being how environment transact to influence development, psychologists today continue to argue on the issue of nature vs nurture. Being dynamic and adept, they too would be able to fulfill the new requirements asked of them. In all their mathematical glory they have missed the essential human need to express individuality. In , American students outperformed their Japanese peers, but Chinese students received the highest scores.
America vs asian education. 10 Big Differences between Asian and American Education Systems
Asian Countries Can Teach the U.S. a Lot About Education - The Atlantic
Scholars would publish articles about how teaching in Taiwan should undergo a reformation in favor of one following the U. However, after spending three months in the U. On the other hand, my sociology professor had the opposite point of view.
Nevertheless, university students in the U. My friend in Hong Kong held tours for Harvard students and found them self-involved. Lauren, my TA, also had a negative experience with American students while she was studying abroad in Paris. It was unbelievable to her why students from such a privileged school failed to behave like decent human beings.
While eastern countries are ignored, Native Americana is swept under the rug. In addition, public schools receive insufficient funding and teachers are underpaid. Although the Obama Administration has worked to reform No Child Left Behind policies, the focus in education, on both the national and state level, continues to be on the testing process.
Another feedback-based faux pas of the system occurs in college, at the end of every semester, when students fill out their teacher evaluations. As a result, student scores barely reflect their real ability.
High GPAs look good on report cards, but they fail to serve their intended purpose, which is to accurately gauge how well students have internalized the course material.
Students in Asia are professional test takers, because since elementary school they are trained to excel in exams and search logically for direct answers. Students in the U. While both sides have their merits, the American attitude of examination would flounder in Asian schools, as the workload is simply too great; there is not enough time to scrutinize every answer epistemologically.
A lot of the coursework in Asian schools requires memorizing, so the mentality is absorb, absorb, absorb. In addition, in Eastern schools, educators place a higher emphasis on teaching world history. Memorizing ancient civilizations and revolutions in Russia is difficult, but at least students in Asia have a better understanding of the world. For instance, I learned a brief history of the U.
When I came to the U. While their ethnocentrism proved challenging, Americans certainly have the leg up on Asian students in terms of positivity.
Where I grew up, people focused too much on getting the right answers, and were accordingly fearful of receiving punishment for mistakes. On the contrary, in the U. However, too much positivity blocks people from seeing reality. In America, teachers, parents and peers give too much praise. Although everyone enjoys compliments, when students receive too much flattery they become complacent.
The fawning over of American students is a double-edged sword, because on the one hand it makes them overconfident and therefore susceptible to mistakes; but, on the other hand, it is this shared, cultural confidence that facilitates the risk-taking that defines American success.
The American Dream, as it were, would be impossible without a kind of panglossian belief in the capability of the self. Ultimately, I think the purpose of education is not just to inform, but to cultivate a desire to learn. In that regard, both the American and Asian systems of education have their benefits. In Asia, a rigorous work ethic, loyalty to community and global sense of perspective serve students well, but a lack of creativity and a discouragement of individuality hamstring student ambition.
In America, the system values diversity, encourages skepticism and promotes audacity, which creates a confident, if somewhat rosy-eyed workforce. Unfortunately, American students are taught solely Western traditions, suffer from the ills of a capitalism-fueled education system and are preened into vulnerability. I am happy to have experienced both systems, as my study abroad has allowed me to see the benefits and demerits of each style of thought, which helps inform my own opinions about which educational methods work best.
For that reason, I again stress the value of study abroad and witnessing different cultures, as doing so allows you to gain a better perspective on the system that created you, as well as its weaknesses and its strengths, which ultimately helps you better understand yourself. Skip to content Toggle navigation. College x April 18, Post Views: 11, Must Read.
Related Posts. Trending Articles. Join the Newsletter.